|
EAJ NEWS No.103 (April 2005)
SUMMARY
Expectation for the Newborn Science Council of Japan (SCJ)
On April 14, 2004, partial amendments of the Science Council of Japan
Law went into the gazette and as from October 2005 SCJ will turn over
the new leaf. On this occasion, I hope that the SCJ will establish such
a framework that it can fully demonstrate its functions of 1) making policy
recommendations to the government, 2) facilitating liaison and coordination
among scientists, 3) communicating with the society, and will properly
fulfill its responsibility to respond to the public mandates.
The public understanding and concern about science and technology issues,
such as the negative effect in line with the advancement of science and
technology and the increased concern about safety matters, have been changing
drastically. In this situation, scientists and engineers are expected
by the public to give neutral, impartial and highly knowledgeable messages
on a non-governmental and non-profitable standpoint about a wide spectrum
of issues related to science and technology.
Based on the above, the Engineering Academy of Japan, which comprises
of members who are in leading positions in industry, academia, and government
with outstanding achievement and a wide scope of knowledge, must play
an active role as follows.
1) Carefully watching environmental changes around science and technology,
EAJ shall research issues to work on, foresee their influence on the
society and appeal to the public with convincing messages from an impartial,
non-political and non-governmental standpoint.
2) Sticking to the private entity, in an individual capacity and from
an integrated stance of academia, industry and government, EAJ shall
welcome the newborn SCJ, strongly support the Council of Science and
Technology Policy, Cabinet and SCJ which are compared to the both wheels
of a car, and shall play a role as a good partner for them.
The 142nd Lecture Meeting "Interim Activity Report of Technological
Literacy Task Force"
The 142nd Lecture Meeting was held on February 3, 2005 to present a progress
report of the activities in the Technological Literacy Task Force. Firstly,
Mr. Hiroshi Sakurai, Chairman of the task force, reviewed the interim
report and then, Emeritus Prof. Shiro Ishii of the Univ. of Tokyo gave
his comments. After that, Emeritus Prof. Haruo Hosoya of Ochanomizu Univ.
talked on "Technology in K-12 Science Education." At the end,
there was a very active exchange of views including 55 participants.
Throughout the discussions, the following issues were identified. ITEA
(International Technology Education Association) in U.S. published a book
"Standards for Technological Literacy" in the year 2000 with
all-out support of National Academy of Engineering (NAE) in U.S.A. Both
the concept and contents proposed in the book are totally different from
those in our ministry's curriculum guidelines for the "technology
& home economics" in Japan. If nothing is done, the education
for children, who are responsible for the future of science and technology
in our country, regarding Technology Literacy (TL), seems extremely pessimistic.
The TL education that is proposed in STL aims at letting children understand
the concept and importance of Technology and acquire the basic knowledge
necessary to participate in the policy making about the technology in
the future. On the other hand, the technology-related education in the
ministry's technology & home economics aims at letting children acquire
technical knowledge necessary for family life. It was pointed out that
MEXT might neither fully understand the principle of technology nor recognize
the importance of such an education.
The conclusion obtained at the lecture meeting is that EAJ play a primary
role in continuously emphasizing the original TL education, making diligent
efforts of illuminating the idea of TL and working hard on the educational
administration till the curriculum guidelines are fundamentally implemented.
The participants in this lecture meeting included teachers of science
courses at junior highs and science journalists. The discussions including
those participants will be reflected in the final report of the Task Force,
and the Open Symposium is also planned.
The 143rd Lecture Meeting on "Recommendation for the Third
Basic Plan for Science and Technology"
The Committee on Technology Policy of EAJ planned the 143rd Lecture Meeting
on February 15, 2005 with a view to reporting the recommendation for the
Third Basic Plan for Science and Technology that the committee drafted
and to exchanging views with EAJ members. Copies of the recommendation
were already distributed to all those concerned and the text was also
put on the EAJ NEWS No.101. In the course of drafting the recommendation,
the committee made an E-mail survey to absorb as many opinions as possible
from EAJ members on this matter. As the recommendation was closely related
to the future five-year science and technology policy of our country and
it was a matter of deep concern to EAJ members, about 40 people attended.
In the beginning, all the attendants offered silent players for Dr. Takeru
Onoda, who played a leading role in drafting the recommendation as Chair
of the Committee and suddenly passed away in January. Then, Vice President
Nakahara, who contributed as facilitator, explained about the gist of
the recommendation and Dr. Iizuka, a committee member, gave an additional
explanation. Vice President Nakahara also referred to the unofficial exchange
of views about the recommendation with several members of the Council
for Science and Technology Policy, Cabinet Office. After that, Prof. Fujio
Niwa, who was newly appointed Chair of the Committee on Technology Policy
as the successor of Dr. Onoda, introduced the result of the review on
the present basic plan that the National Institute of Science and Technology
Policy (NISTEP) conducted.
The recommendation suggests that the Third Basic Plan should be positioned
as a problem-solving strategy toward unprecedented environmental changes
anticipated in the future and as a knowledge-oriented strategy to overcome
restrictions on a global basis. The major points that EAJ recommended
are: in the internationally tense relations in the future, priority should
be given to national interests about comprehensive security system of
our country; regarding securing of human resources, it is important to
foster people who have a wide vision integrating knowledge oriented from
humanity & social science and that from natural science & engineering
as well as strong leadership; the assessment system of the plan should
be enhanced and in particular the ex-post assessment should be reflected
in the next plan.
For the recommendation covering wide range of issues including those
described above, a variety of opinions were given by the attendants such
as enhancement of discretionary authority of the Council for Science and
Technology Policy, partial allocation of defense budget to R&D in
private sector, reinforcement of software development, focus on problem-solving
strategy. The view commonly pointed out by the attendants was that the
words and phrases used in the recommendation were difficult to understand
and that plain and commonly- used expressions should be used. Nevertheless,
the recommendation is extremely suggestive and appropriate. We strongly
wish EAJ's recommendation will be accepted by the Council for Science
and Technology Policy and be reflected in the Third Basic Plan.
The 144th Lecture Meeting "d-commerce Declaration: 8 Necessary
Requirements for the Content Business for 2010; Metadata Changes Content
Delivery"
Digital Commerce Task Force of EAJ, which was established in April 2002
with Prof. Hiroshi Yasuda as chair, had worked on 'Digital Content Delivery
through Broad Band network' in cooperation with the committee of the Science
Council of Japan chaired by Prof. Shigeo Tsujii. The Task Force planned
a lecture meeting on February 25, 2005 to report the result of their activities.
Prof. Hiroshi Yasuda, as soon as he recognized attending members, he
modified his ppt slides and talked about metadata technology in addition
to the activity report.
The explosive growth of Internet and the digital content delivered through
Internet posed technological challenges such as content production, IPR
management including digital rights, consumer and privacy protection,
and Internet taxation. Prof. Yasuda stressed the importance of international
conformity and introduced information technology that will not hamper
the Internet expansion.
He also analyzed the reasons for the slower growth of IT business compared
to the expansion of broad band and proposed necessary requirements to
foster IT business to be USD 50 billion market by the year 2010. Digital
content-related problems include 'a change of media alone will not make
a new market', 'insufficient content, which is a network specific problem',
'incomplete IT gadget that enables individuals to easily produce content."
Problems inherit in values of Internet users include deep-rooted sense
of 'free', 'unauthorized use' and 'reformable.' Metadata technology is
the core technology for effective content production, for QC (quality
control) such as reliability of information, for advertisement of goods
and information service, for accumulation and search of digital knowledge,
for digital right management and for infomediary service. This is what
he proposes as 'Digital-Commerce.' In order to appeal to the industry,
academia, government and the people, a book "d-commerce Declaration:
8 Necessary Requirements for the Content Business for 2010" was published.
d-commerce Declaration: Digital Content, Orderly,
Metadata, Mediating, Electronic, Rights, Communication,
Economics
The 145th Lecture Meeting "Features of the Sumatra-Andaman
Islands Earthquake and the Role of Geoscientists"
The 145th Lecture Meeting was held on March 4 inviting Dr. Satoru Ohya,
Advisor of OYO Corporation and EAJ member. He graduated from Geology Department,
School of Science, Univ. of Tokyo in 1953. He has served as president
of Society of Exploration of Geophysicists of Japan, as board member of
geoscience section, Stanford Univ. and also participates in the activities
of international NPOs. Despite the snowfall in the morning, the meeting
enjoyed about 30 attendances.
The Sumatra-Andaman Islands Earthquake is estimated to have the magnitude
of 9 and is the fourth largest earthquake in the world since 1900. The
rupture zone judged from the aftershock distribution was over 1,100km.
A large part of about 300,000 missing and dead were victims of tsunami.
80% of them were Indonesian, and Thai, Sri Lanka and Africa were also
affected. The photos to report the disaster-affected city of Banda Aceh
at the Northwestern tip of the Sumatra Island were awful and made us feel
how strong and merciless the Nature's destructive force was.
The study of geological structure and earthquake distribution ranging
from Myanmar to the Sumatra Island raised concerns of an earthquake likely
to occur in Myanmar which was an extension of the earthquake fault this
time, due to subduction of the Indo-Australian plate under the Burma Micro
Plate.
In the end, Dr. Ohya raised questions 'Were those big earthquakes and
tsunami predictable?' and 'Were education and illumination sufficiently
given to the public?', and at the same time he referred to the importance
of comprehensively using knowledge to disaster-prevention practice and
the role that Japan should play in the international society.
Topics discussed after the lecture included the importance of education
to the general public, responsibility of experts, prediction of earthquakes
and tsunamis, way for information disclosure, real-time prevention of
earthquake disaster, restriction for housing area, preventive measures,
lack of record of earthquake information.
Newsletter Forum: Proposal of "The Kagakugijutsu (Science-and-Technology)"
Academy
by Tokuta Inoue, EAJ member
The name of our academy is 'The Engineering Academy of Japan.'
About 'Engineering' a lot of discussions and considerations have already
been made so far, but I would like to reconsider about this matter from
a wider point of view.
We have the word 'Kagakugijutsu (Science-and-Technology' in Japan. This
'Kagakugijutsu' means neither 'science and technology' nor 'science or technology.'
It is the mixing concept. If I were to say, it might be 'a human-centered
system of knowledge and skill.' I suggest 'Engineering' should be read as
'Kagakugijutsu' in this sense and that 'The Engineering Academy of Japan'
should be understood as 'The Kagakugijutsu Academy of Japan.' I do not mean
the changing of the name but just the understanding of the concept.
Science is useful for humankind only when it is applied as technology.
'Engineers' are 'a group of experts who can use science and technology for
the welfare of humankind.' When we define so, at least 'medical scientists
and agricultural scientists' pursue the same mission. So, I wonder if they
could join 'The Kagakugijutsu Academy of Japan' as 'professionals of biology-related
Kagakugijutsu' in a broad sense. Medical scientists and agricultural scientists
with engineering background and engineers with medical and agricultural
background are already included in EAJ members, but I would like to actively
invite more of those people.
Last year, a book 'Genome Defeat' written by Prof. Nobuhito Kishi enjoyed
a good reputation. Despite advanced research and proposals in human genomic
analysis made by Japanese scientists starting from Dr. Akiyoshi Wada, why
did Japan fall behind of Western countries? I am sure that everyone will
not read the book without feeling a deep regret. In the reasons summarized
in the page 171, a collaboration gap between 'scientists with physical background'
and 'scientists with biological and medical background' in Japan is pointed
out.
Meanwhile, I have recently read a book 'Life Science Strategy of NIH.'
It was impressive to learn about the member composition of 2,800 engineering
scientists versus 2,000 medical scientists even more than the scale and
function of NIH. Problems that cannot be solved by experts of single field
pile up and a move to remove barriers between fields of science and technology
is accelerated. In this situation, if our Engineering Academy of Japan were
to strengthen its influence to the public, not only increasing members but
also expanding fields of expertise would be necessary.
Additionally, at the 145th Lecture Meeting, the audience learned from Dr.
Ohya's talk on "Features of the Sumatra-Andaman Islands Earthquake
and the Role of Geoscientists" that the matter required a great diversification
from science, engineering into social system, policy-making and education.
Those who are in the fields of social science and humanity and are also
interested in engineering science or Kagakugijutsu should be highly encouraged
to participate in 'The Engineering Academy.'
What is the most important role of 'The Engineering Academy' intensified
in this way? One is the 'recommendation.' This is what the successive presidents
have emphasized and members have also been very conscious of, but frankly
it is not yet satisfactory in my opinion in terms of concreteness, clarity
of the point and influence.
I strongly wish 'The Engineering Academy of Japan' will hold members covering
a wide range of fields of expertise and make vigorous 'recommendations'
several times a year.
Obituary
Kinjiro Aso, Prof. Emeritus of Kyushu Univ. passed away on Jan.6, 2005
at the age of 85.
Ichimatsu Tanishita, Prof. Emeritus of Keio Univ. and ex-President of
Kanagawa Institute of Technology, passed away at the age of 98.
May they rest in peace.
|